Justice Anthony Kennedy retiring

[JDHURF]

[exploited]

[JDHURF]

To anyone scientifically literate it's clear. It's clear because an operational definition is dependent upon the methodology of the study. The operational definition employed in Lalit Kumar, Radha Krishna and Rayan Alsuwaigh, 2015. Understanding the Fluid Nature of Personhood - The Ring Theory of Personhood, is operationally different from that of Emile Tsékénis, 2017. Personhood, Collectives, and the Human-Animal Distinction: The Cases of the Cameroon Grassfields and Madagascar, which, in turn, is different from that of Masha Komolova, Monisha Pasupathi, Cecilia Wainryb, Sarah Lucas, 2016. Children's and adolescents' conceptions of personhood A narrative approach, etc., etc. Common to them all are precisely the attributes Singer cited that I quoted.

[exploited]

You still have not provided an operational definition of personhood, let alone related that definition to the various stages of human development.

[The Comrade]

viability outside of the womb is a good metric. it's not longer a parasite then.

[JDHURF]

A first approximation for those who are clearly not versed in the science of psychology, sociology, anthropology, primatology, zoology, etc., etc.: Personhood is an emergent property of the functioning of the neuroarchitecture.

A glimpse into the methodological variations in operational definition: embodied individual human or nonhuman animal with being, self and agentic capability; intentional agency and the capacity to recognize other intentional agents; rational, self-conscious being with awareness of biographical self; reasoning and reflecting being with the capacity to consider itself as itself; sentient self-conscious being with rationality, self-awareness and autonomy.

I am not interested in conducting an online introductory course on personhood for individuals who are clearly not interested in conducting the most minimal research, even after being given several scientific citations.

It is clear that the developing organism after conception does not at any point in utero embody any of the traits defining the methodologically varied operational definitions.

As I've already specified, none of this may be trivialized and must be considered corresponding to the specificities. I made this explicitly clear with reference to a woman whose pregnancy induced illness such that birth would've resulted in her death to a stillbirth.

[exploited]

You just repeated the same concept six different ways, and excluded children under the age of fifteen months from the concept of personhood.

We're done here. Carry on, you f**k moron.

[exploited]

[The Comrade]

I didn't say it was based on personhood

[exploited]