by Spider » Fri Sep 05, 2014 5:08 pm
Depends on the type of wine, IMO. California does great with sauvignon blanc, cabernet and chardonnay, Oregon does better with the pinots, washington does better with Riesling and gewurtz, Australia kicks ass with Syrah/Shiraz, and France is still pretty dominant with a lot of sparklers and old school burgundy blend stuff. Or so its said. Italy has the best sparkling wine, imo, and definately the best fortified wine, tied only with spain. Italy also rocks the rose. Well, and the sangiovese.
Hard to pick an area that is objectively the best. I agree though that French wine is wildly overestimated...as consistently shows up in blind tastings. I've never had a french champagne I've been even remotely impressed with. And people go on and on about that stuff. American sparklers are way better, at least IMO.
France's wine industry is so inflexible that they are suffering in much the same way german beer is. Self-limited by self-aggrandizement. Who cares how your great gran-cester from century X did it? Be creative. Roll with the times. Don't stifle yourselves with dogmatism.