I don't understand where you're coming from about not electing Judges.
Are you saying they should just be like regular public sector employees?
If that's the case, I think they would never be held accountable.
As for rights, I partially agree with you. I'm all for people paying their debt to society, and getting on with their lives.
I've known a couple of guys who have successfully patetioned to get their rights back. But, that's just anecdotal evedence on my part, and I honestly don't know the statistics of that sucessfully happening. I'm sure it's probably pretty slim.
Even though your view is pretty consistent, I don't think you are taking into account that there are some bad seeds in the world, and they're going to be violent an repeat offenders no matter what. That's why I asked about firearms possession.
I'm sure if reforms along the line of you're thinking were enacted, Maybe there'd be less of these repeat offenders.