Orientations toward religion

[JDHURF]

[Stratego]

[JDHURF]

You are still not making sense. If A does not equal B there is clearly both a case, separately, where "it's not A" and also a case where "it's not B."[1] When you add "...but also B" to the case "where it's not A" what is that supposed to mean? Also B in addition to what? In assuming that either A or B are the only two available options, for the sake of your attempted demonstration, clearly it is either A or B and not both simultaneously. If it's not A then clearly it's B. If it's not B then clearly it's A. When it is not one of the two, it is clearly the other but not in addition to anything else, it is that proposition alone. So, again, it is meaningless when you mention the "case where it's not A, but also B..."

Is there a case where someone says "I believe there is(are) no god(s)" and not "I do not believe in god(s)"(not A but B)? Sure. Is there a case where someone says "I do not believe in god(s)" and not "I believe there is(are) no god(s)"(not B but A)? Absolutely.

You conclusion is a complete non sequitur and your premises are a mess themselves.

[1] You may have begun to go awry when you used "it's not A" to signify when it is B and vice versa. That lends more easily to confusion than to clarity.

[spacemonkey]

[JDHURF]

Why quote the entirety of my extensive post if you're not even going to address a single of the substantive points made?

I find it perfectly irrelevant that ancient societies were able to perform incredible feats in architecture and so on, often through slave labor. That is not evidence of the supernatural. That is only evidence of human ingenuity.

[spacemonkey]

[JDHURF]

Actually, there is a right way and a wrong way to draw conclusions from what is reviewed. Nothing the ancients did serves as evidence of the supernatural which is why you ignored my questions searching for specificity that began my response.

[spacemonkey]

[JDHURF]

Created what stuff? You refuse to be specific. Cite for me which specific artifacts you believe serve as evidence of the supernatural and give me the reasons why you believe the artifacts serve as such evidence.

[The Dharma Bum]

Mankind has created some inexplicable artifacts throughout history. Not saying I know what this means, but it's weird and was created sometime in the middle ages:


What do you make of that?